Orangeville: (519) 940 - 8309
Fergus: (519) 772-6139
Fax: (519) 940 - 0526

Criminal Record Checks in Ontario: What Employers Can See

What an employer sees depends entirely on which type of check was requested. A criminal record check and a vulnerable sector check are different documents governed by different rules, and the Police Record Checks Reform Act, 2015 sets out exactly what each one may contain.

The Act came into force on November 1, 2018. Before it, police services across Ontario disclosed different things on the same request. Since then, what may appear on a check has been fixed by a table in the Schedule to the Act, and anything not authorized for that type of check cannot be released.

Request a Consultation

How Foote Law Can Help

Foote Law advises on what a record check will show and on the steps that can change it. Services include:

  • Advice on which of the three checks an employer has requested and what the Act permits it to contain.
  • Review of a check already received, against what the Act authorizes for that type of check.
  • Requests for reconsideration where a vulnerable sector check discloses non-conviction information.
  • Applications for a record suspension, and advice on the waiting period and when it begins.
  • Submissions on the Crown’s election (its choice to proceed summarily or by indictment) and on sentence, including a discharge where the offence permits one, with a view to what each outcome leaves on the record.
  • Defence of a charge where a conviction would affect employment, a professional licence, or immigration status.

Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, Centre Wellington, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.

The Three Types of Police Record Check

Section 8(1) of the Act requires every police service to conduct three types of police record check:

  • A criminal record check.
  • A criminal record and judicial matters check.
  • A vulnerable sector check.

Section 8(2) allows certain other providers, including third-party entities, to conduct the same checks where an agreement or federal law permits it. Whoever conducts the check, section 9 is the controlling rule: a provider shall not disclose information in response to a request unless the information is authorized to be disclosed in connection with the particular type of check in accordance with the Schedule.

For people who work with children in certain settings, a fourth check now applies. This broad record check is created not by this Act but by regulation under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, and it is explained later in this article.

What Each Check Can Disclose

The Schedule to the Act sets out nine categories of information and, for each, the checks on which it may appear:

  • Convictions. Every criminal offence of which the individual has been convicted, and for which no pardon has been issued or granted, may be disclosed on all three checks. However, a conviction for an offence that can be prosecuted only by summary conviction is not disclosed if the request is made more than five years after the date of the conviction. A hybrid offence, which the Crown may prosecute either way, does not fall within this limit even where it was prosecuted summarily.
  • Youth findings. Every finding of guilt under the Youth Criminal Justice Act may be disclosed on all three checks, but only during the access period that Act allows. Those periods are set out below.
  • Absolute discharges. An offence for which the individual received an absolute discharge is not disclosed on a criminal record check. It may be disclosed on the other two, but not if the request is made more than one year after the date of the discharge.
  • Conditional discharges. An offence for which the individual received a conditional discharge is not disclosed on a criminal record check. It may be disclosed on the other two, but not if the request is made more than three years after the date of the discharge.
  • Outstanding charges and warrants. An offence for which there is an outstanding charge or a warrant to arrest is not disclosed on a criminal record check, and may be disclosed on the other two.
  • Court orders. A court order made against the individual is not disclosed on a criminal record check, and may be disclosed on the other two. Three kinds of order are excluded even there: orders made under the Mental Health Act or Part XX.1 of the Criminal Code, which deals with mental disorder; orders made in relation to a charge that was withdrawn; and restraining orders under the Family Law Act, the Children’s Law Reform Act, or the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017.
  • Findings of not criminally responsible. A charge that resulted in a finding of not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder may be disclosed on a vulnerable sector check only. It is not disclosed if the request is made more than five years after the finding, or if the individual received an absolute discharge.
  • Pardoned convictions. A conviction for which a pardon has been granted is not disclosed on any of the three checks unless the Criminal Records Act authorizes it. For this purpose, the Schedule treats a record suspension as a pardon.
  • Non-conviction information. Information authorized for exceptional disclosure under section 10 may be disclosed on a vulnerable sector check only.

In practice, the criminal record check, the most basic of the three, shows only convictions and youth findings. Outstanding charges, discharges, and court orders appear only where a criminal record and judicial matters check or a vulnerable sector check has been requested.

Discharges, and When They Come Off the System

A discharge under section 730 of the Criminal Code is not a conviction: section 730(3) deems the offender not to have been convicted of the offence, apart from limited exceptions such as the right to appeal. A discharge still appears on some checks for a period.

Section 6.1(1) of the Criminal Records Act prohibits disclosure of a record of a discharge without the prior approval of the Minister once more than one year has passed since an absolute discharge, or more than three years since the offender was ordered discharged on the conditions in a probation order. Section 6.1(2) goes further: at the end of that period, the Commissioner of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police must remove all references to the discharge from the RCMP’s automated criminal conviction records retrieval system.

These federal periods match the Schedule’s one-year and three-year limits. A person who received an absolute discharge two years ago is therefore outside both, and the discharge cannot appear on any of the three checks.

Withdrawn and Dismissed Charges

The Act defines non-conviction information as the fact that an individual was charged with a criminal offence where the charge was dismissed, withdrawn, or stayed, or ended in an acquittal. Under the Schedule, this information may be disclosed on a vulnerable sector check only, and only if it meets the exceptional disclosure test in section 10. Section 10(2) permits that disclosure only where all three of the following conditions are met:

  • The charge is for an offence specified in the regulations made under section 22(2)(c).
  • The alleged victim was a child or a vulnerable person.
  • After reviewing the entries about the individual, the provider has reasonable grounds to believe that the individual has been engaged in a pattern of predation indicating that the individual presents a risk of harm to a child or a vulnerable person.

In assessing the third condition, the provider considers whether the individual appears to have targeted a child or a vulnerable person, whether the behaviour was repeated and directed at more than one victim, when it occurred, the number of incidents, the reason it did not lead to a conviction, and any other considerations prescribed by regulation. On the other two checks, a withdrawn or dismissed charge cannot be disclosed at all.

Youth Findings of Guilt

A finding of guilt under the Youth Criminal Justice Act may be disclosed on any of the three checks, but only while the access period for that record remains open. Section 119(2) of that Act sets the access periods for youth records, including records of charges that did not end in a finding of guilt:

  • Two years after the young person consents to an extrajudicial sanction.
  • Two months after the time allowed for an appeal expires, where the young person was acquitted other than by a verdict of not criminally responsible, or three months after any appeal is completed.
  • Two months after a charge is dismissed or withdrawn, or after a finding of guilt where a reprimand is given.
  • One year after a charge is stayed, if no proceedings are taken during that year.
  • Six months after the expiry of an order made under section 14(2) or 20(2) of that Act.
  • One year after a finding of guilt where an absolute discharge was given.
  • Three years after a finding of guilt where a conditional discharge was given.
  • Three years after a youth sentence for a summary conviction offence is completed.
  • Five years after a youth sentence for an indictable offence is completed.

These periods can be extended. A further offence committed as a young person during the access period for a summary or indictable offence lengthens it, and under section 119(9), a conviction for an offence committed as an adult during that period turns the youth record into an adult record.

Where a youth finding is disclosed, section 11 of the Police Record Checks Reform Act, 2015 requires it to be set out in a separate record from any other information disclosed about the individual.

A Record Suspension

Record suspensions replaced pardons in 2012, although pardons granted before then remain in effect under the former rules. Under section 6(2) of the Criminal Records Act, a record of a conviction for which a record suspension has been ordered is kept separate and apart from other criminal records, and is not disclosed without the prior approval of the Minister. Section 6(3) requires the Minister, before granting that approval, to be satisfied that the disclosure is desirable in the interests of the administration of justice or for a purpose related to the safety or security of Canada or an allied state.

One route survives a record suspension. Section 6.3(2) requires the Commissioner to make a notation in the RCMP’s automated system that allows a police force or other authorized body to determine whether an individual has a suspended conviction for an offence listed in Schedule 2 to the Act. The offences in Schedule 2 include abduction of a person under 16 under section 280 of the Criminal Code and indecent communications under subsection 372(2).

Under section 6.3(3), a person or organization responsible for the well-being of a child or vulnerable person may ask police to check for that notation when it receives an application for a paid or volunteer position of trust or authority toward that child or vulnerable person. The applicant must consent in writing. Section 6.3(4) prohibits any other verification, and section 6.3(8) allows an organization that receives the information to use it only in assessing that application.

Foote Law’s guide to criminal record suspensions in Ontario sets out the application process and the waiting periods.

The Broad Record Check for Children’s Services

The three statutory checks have limits. Nothing in the Schedule provides for disclosing a call for service, an apprehension under the Mental Health Act, or a police contact that produced a record but no charge, and court orders under the Mental Health Act are expressly excluded. For people who work with children in certain settings, a fourth check reaches further.

Two regulations took effect on January 1, 2025. O. Reg. 307/24 under the Police Record Checks Reform Act, 2015 exempts the broad record check from that Act. O. Reg. 308/24 under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 amends O. Reg. 155/18 to set out when a broad record check is required, how often checks must be renewed, and what organizations must do with the results.

A broad record check discloses more than a vulnerable sector check. Subject to limited exceptions, it includes every contact between the person and a police service for which the police service has a written record, and certain contacts with police under the Mental Health Act.

Anyone who provides care directly to a child or young person in licensed residential care, whether as an employee, volunteer, or student, must provide a broad record check, as must the officers and directors of a corporation that holds the licence. The check must be renewed at least every three years, with an offence declaration in each year between. A person must also give written notice as soon as possible after being charged with or convicted of an offence under the Criminal Code, and organizations must keep written policies on how checks are obtained, used, and kept confidential.

Who Can Request a Check, and Who Sees the Result

Section 7(1) allows an individual to request a check on themselves, and section 7(2) allows a person or organization to request one about an individual. Both requests must be in writing. Section 7(4) requires the request to specify the particular type of check, and section 7(5) requires it to include any applicable fee.

The Act does not limit an organization to the type of check suited to the position, so an employer is not barred by this statute from requesting a vulnerable sector check for a role that involves no vulnerable people. The safeguard is section 8(3): a provider shall not conduct a check unless the request contains the individual’s written consent to the particular type of check. Consent to a criminal record check is not consent to a vulnerable sector check.

Section 12(1) then decides who sees the result. The provider discloses the results to the individual who is the subject of the check and to no one else. Under section 12(2), once the individual has received the results and gives written consent, the provider may give a copy to the organization that requested the check, or to another person or organization the individual names. An applicant therefore sees what the check says before the employer does, and decides whether to release it.

The Act does not set a general expiry date for a completed check. A check reports what the records showed on the day it was run, and how recent a check must be is usually a matter of the organization’s own policy. The exceptions arise where the law sets a period, as the children’s services regulations do with their three-year renewal cycle. The Act also allows regulations to limit how long a check for a volunteer may be relied on.

Whether an Employer Can Refuse a Job Over a Record

Section 5(1) of Ontario’s Human Rights Code gives every person a right to equal treatment with respect to employment without discrimination because of, among other grounds, record of offences.

The protection is narrower than the phrase suggests. Section 10(1) defines “record of offences” as a conviction for an offence in respect of which a pardon has been granted under the Criminal Records Act and has not been revoked, or for an offence under a provincial enactment. An unpardoned criminal conviction falls outside the definition, so the Code does not prohibit an employer from refusing to hire on that basis.

What the Code does protect is a provincial conviction, such as one under the Highway Traffic Act, and a federal conviction for which a pardon has been granted and not revoked.

The RCMP Certified Criminal Record Check

A certified criminal record check, which the RCMP conducts using fingerprints, is a separate document from a police record check conducted by a local police service. Some organizations require one, for example for federal government employment. What it discloses depends on the purpose for which it is requested.

A certified check for federal government employment discloses conviction information, youth information, outstanding charges, and active absolute or conditional discharge information. For Transport Canada employment, it also discloses non-conviction information.

A certified vulnerable sector check discloses conviction information, active absolute or conditional discharge information where the person also has convictions on file, and suspended (pardoned) information, which is released only with the Minister’s approval. A certified check for a citizenship application discloses conviction information, youth information, outstanding charges, active discharge information, non-conviction information, and immigration information.

An applicant asked for a check for immigration, citizenship, or a federal position may therefore face a different disclosure standard from someone applying for an ordinary job in Ontario.

What a Check Costs and How to Apply

Each police service sets its own fee, although under section 7(6) of the Act, police services may not charge for a criminal record check or a criminal record and judicial matters check that relates to volunteering. The figures below are as published by each service in October 2026 and should be confirmed before relying on them.

Ontario Provincial Police

The Ontario Provincial Police, which has policed Orangeville since October 2020, charges $41.00 for a record check and $90.00 for fingerprints, and charges no fee for a volunteer check. It offers the three statutory checks and an OPP Non-Parent Custody Check, which is also the route for a broad record check. Applications are made online, identity is verified through the OPP’s third-party vendor, and an application is treated as abandoned if identity verification or fingerprinting is not provided within 60 days.

Municipal Police Services

Fees differ among municipal police services. The Toronto Police Service, for example, charges $26.72 for a criminal record check or a criminal record and judicial matters check for employment, and nothing for a volunteer. A vulnerable sector check costs $71.72 for employment and $26.72 for a volunteer, a broad record check costs $71.72, and vulnerable sector fingerprinting costs $25.00.

The Toronto Police Service requires two pieces of government-issued identification: one bearing a photograph and signature, and one bearing the full name and date of birth. Fingerprints are mandatory on a vulnerable sector check whenever the applicant’s gender and date of birth match an existing pardoned sexual offence record. This is a match on those two details only, not a finding about the applicant.

Challenging What a Check Discloses

Where non-conviction information is disclosed on a vulnerable sector check, O. Reg. 348/18 requires the record given to the individual to explain the reconsideration process. The individual may request a reconsideration in writing within 45 days of receiving the record, and may include written submissions. Under section 10(4) of the Act, the provider must reconsider its decision within 30 days of receiving the request, and under section 10(5), the information shall not be disclosed if the provider then decides it does not meet the section 10(2) criteria.

Because section 12(1) puts the result in the applicant’s hands first, the reconsideration can take place before any employer sees the information.

Concerned About What a Record Check Will Show?

A withdrawn charge, an absolute discharge, and an unpardoned conviction are treated differently on each of the three checks, and that difference can decide whether an employer sees anything at all. Early legal advice, ideally from the first court appearance, leaves the most room to protect the record. Foote Law reviews what a check discloses, seeks reconsideration of non-conviction entries, and defends charges with the record consequences in view. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.

Request a Consultation

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D.

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D. is a Barrister and Solicitor and the Founder of Foote Law in Orangeville, Ontario. She earned her Juris Doctor from Osgoode Hall Law School and her Honours Bachelor of Business Administration and Management from the University of Guelph. Her legal experience includes family law, criminal law, real estate, and wills and estates. Jessica is committed to providing approachable, client-focused legal guidance and helping individuals and families understand their legal options. She is also actively involved in legal education, professional organisations, and community initiatives throughout Dufferin County and the surrounding areas.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.