Disclaimer
The information provided in this blog and the website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this blog does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
Most parenting disputes in Ontario are resolved by agreement between the parents. When a judge must decide, the outcome turns on two things: the best interests of the child and the evidence that is actually before the court. On a temporary motion, the arrangement already in place can carry particular weight, which is why the early stages of a case often shape how it ends.
Although the phrase “child custody” remains in common use, Ontario law now speaks of “decision-making responsibility” and “parenting time.” Decision-making responsibility concerns the major decisions in a child’s life, such as schooling, health care, and religion. Parenting time refers to the time a child spends in each parent’s care.
Under section 24 of the Children’s Law Reform Act, the court must give primary consideration to the child’s physical, emotional, and psychological safety, security, and well-being. The full list of factors is set out in Foote Law’s complete guide to child custody and parenting arrangements in Ontario. This article explains how a court applies those factors in practice.
How Foote Law Can Help
A contested parenting case moves through several stages, and the work done at each one affects the next. Foote Law represents parents throughout the process, including:
• Preparing the application, answer, and supporting affidavits.
• Bringing or responding to motions for temporary parenting orders where a decision cannot wait.
• Assembling the documentary evidence the court relies on.
• Making submissions on whether an assessment or an Office of the Children’s Lawyer investigation is warranted.
• Representing clients at case conferences, settlement conferences, and trial management conferences.
• Representing clients at trial in the Ontario Court of Justice and the Superior Court of Justice.
Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Centre Wellington, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.
The Steps in a Parenting Case
Under Rule 5 of the Family Law Rules, a case about decision-making responsibility or parenting time is started in the municipality where the child habitually resides, except as provided for under section 22 of the Children’s Law Reform Act. From there, a contested case generally follows these steps:
1. Application and answer. The applicant sets out the orders being sought. The respondent then states which claims are admitted and which are disputed, and may make claims of their own.
2. Case conference. This is usually the first substantive court appearance. A judge meets with the parties to identify the issues in dispute, address disclosure, and set out the next steps.
3. Motion for a temporary order. Where a decision cannot wait for trial, a party may ask the court for a temporary parenting order. Under Rule 14, a motion is ordinarily heard only after a case conference, although the court may hear one earlier in a situation of urgency or hardship. The evidence is usually given by affidavit, and oral testimony requires the court’s permission.
4. Disclosure, reports, and assessments. The parties exchange documents, and any involvement by the Office of the Children’s Lawyer or a parenting assessment is arranged.
5. Settlement conference. A judge reviews the issues, may offer a view on the likely outcome, and attempts to help the parties resolve the case.
6. Trial management conference. The court confirms that the case is ready, estimates the length of the trial, and schedules it.
7. Trial. Witnesses testify and are cross-examined, and the judge makes a final order.
Many cases end well before trial. A negotiated settlement is typically recorded in minutes of settlement and then converted into a final order on consent.
The First Motion Matters Most
On a motion for a temporary parenting order, an established status quo is an important consideration. Courts are generally reluctant to disturb a stable arrangement unless there is compelling evidence that a change is required in the child’s best interests.
Where a parent asks the court to change an established arrangement on a temporary basis, Ontario courts have required compelling evidence that clearly and unequivocally establishes that the existing arrangement is not in the child’s best interests. The analysis focuses on how a change would affect the child, not on what either parent would prefer.
The practical consequence is significant. The arrangement in place when the first motion is heard can remain in place for much of the case, and it may influence what a court is prepared to order at trial.
What the Court Reads
A temporary motion is usually decided on paper. The judge reads the affidavits and the documents attached to them, and the material that carries the most weight is the material that can be verified. Useful evidence commonly includes:
• Communication records, such as text messages, emails, and co-parenting application logs, which are valuable because they are time-stamped.
• A record of the parenting time actually exercised, including any dates missed and the reasons given.
• School records, including attendance, report cards, and any individual education plan.
• Medical and therapy records relevant to the child’s needs.
• Evidence of the caregiving each parent has provided, such as appointments attended and arrangements made.
• Observations from teachers, coaches, physicians, and others who are not aligned with either parent.
By contrast, assertions about the other parent’s character carry little weight unless they are supported by documents or a neutral witness.
When the Office of the Children’s Lawyer Becomes Involved
In a parenting case, the court may ask the Office of the Children’s Lawyer to become involved. The Office then decides whether to accept the case. It may decline in a number of circumstances, including where a children’s aid society is actively investigating, where the child does not live in Ontario, or where support or property issues are the main focus and the parenting arrangements are relatively stable.
When the Office accepts a case, it may assign a lawyer, a clinician, or both. The lawyer represents the child and advances the child’s views and preferences. The clinician, usually a social worker, meets with the family, investigates, and prepares a report for the court.
Section 30 Assessments
Under section 30(1) of the Children’s Law Reform Act, the court may appoint a person with technical or professional skill to assess and report on the needs of the child and on the ability and willingness of the parties to meet those needs. The assessor is ordinarily a psychologist, psychiatrist, or social worker.
An assessment is not ordered as a matter of course. The party seeking one must justify it, and the courts have held that assessments should not be ordered routinely or used simply as a tool to promote settlement. The question is fact-driven and flexible:
an assessment may be ordered where expert input is reasonably necessary to help the court decide material parenting issues.
Assessments can take months to complete, and the parties pay for them. Under section 30(14), the court may relieve a party of responsibility for some or all of the fees where payment would cause serious financial hardship.
How Reports Are Treated Before Trial
A court may be cautious about relying on an assessment or an Office of the Children’s Lawyer report on a temporary motion. At that stage, the author usually has not been cross-examined on their qualifications, their methods, or their conclusions.
Where a report is considered, the court looks closely at the process behind it, including the number of meetings held and whether recognized assessment standards were followed. A report produced through a process the court regards as unsound may be given less weight. In every case, the recommendation in a report is evidence; the decision belongs to the court.
How the Factors Are Weighed
The statutory factors are not a checklist in which each item carries equal weight. The court gives primary consideration to the child’s safety, security, and well-being, and weighs the remaining factors against the circumstances of the particular child.
Two factors are often especially important in practice. The first is the history of care, which shows who has actually been meeting the child’s needs and is difficult to contradict with assertions alone. The second is each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent. The court assesses this factor on conduct rather than stated intention, so a parent who obstructs the other parent’s relationship with the child may be supplying evidence against themselves.
Conduct That Damages a Parent’s Position
The conduct that most often harms a parent’s case is conduct aimed at the other parent rather than focused on the child. Common examples include:
• Withholding parenting time, or returning the child late, without a genuine safety concern.
• Speaking negatively about the other parent where the child can hear.
• Using the child to carry messages or to report on the other household.
• Making allegations that cannot be substantiated.
• Refusing to communicate about the child’s schooling, health, or activities.
Sustained conduct of this kind may amount to parental alienation. Courts assess alienation as a pattern of behaviour rather than as isolated incidents, and it must be proved on a balance of probabilities. Foote Law’s guide to parental alienation in Ontario explains how the courts identify and respond to it.
What a Final Order Contains
A final parenting order allocates decision-making responsibility, sets a parenting schedule that includes holidays and school breaks, and provides for communication between the child and each parent.
An order may also set out how the parents are to communicate with one another, require exchanges to take place at a particular location or under supervision, restrict the geographic area in which the child may live, and address travel and passport arrangements. Careful drafting matters at this stage: the issues an order leaves unaddressed are often the issues that bring parents back to court.
Facing a Parenting Dispute?
A contested parenting case is decided on the child’s best interests and on the evidence before the court, and the arrangement in place at the first motion can carry significant weight. Obtaining legal advice early, before that first motion is heard, gives a parent the best opportunity to protect their position and their child’s stability.
Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.
