Disclaimer
The information provided in this blog and the website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this blog does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
For most separating couples in Ontario family court, the case conference is the first real meeting with a judge. It is not a trial, and no one gives evidence. It is, however, where a judge first looks at the substance of the dispute, encourages the parties toward settlement, and sets the path the case will follow. It also acts as a gate: under the Family Law Rules, neither party can serve or argue a motion on the issues in dispute until a case conference has been held.
Rule 17(1) requires a judge to conduct at least one conference in every case in which an answer is filed, subject to exceptions for child protection and international child abduction cases. Orders can be made at a case conference, and costs can be awarded against a party who arrives unprepared. Preparation matters as much here as at any later stage of the case.
How Foote Law Can Help
Foote Law acts for parties at every stage of a family court case, and the case conference is often where careful early work pays off most. Foote Law’s services include:
• Preparing the case conference brief and updating the financial statement.
• Serving and filing documents within the deadlines set by the Rules and the applicable practice directions.
• Conferring with the other party before the conference, as the Rules require.
• Representation at the conference itself.
• Urgent motions where a case cannot wait for a conference date.
• Negotiating and drafting agreements reached at or after the conference.
Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Centre Wellington, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.
What a Case Conference Is For
Rule 17(4) sets out eleven purposes. Taken together, they show that a case conference is as much about organizing the case as it is about settling it:
• Exploring the chances of settling the case.
• Identifying the issues that are in dispute and those that are not.
• Exploring ways to resolve the issues that are in dispute.
• Ensuring disclosure of the relevant evidence, including the financial information required to resolve any support or property issue.
• Identifying any issues relating to expert evidence or reports the parties intend to rely on at trial.
• Noting admissions that may simplify the case.
• Setting the date for the next step in the case.
• Setting a specific timetable for the steps to be taken before trial.
• Organizing a settlement conference, or holding one if appropriate.
• Giving directions on any intended motion, including a timetable for exchanging material.
• On a motion to change a final order or agreement under Rule 15, determining the most appropriate process for reaching a quick and just conclusion.
Why a Motion Has to Wait
Under Rule 14(4), no notice of motion or supporting evidence may be served, and no motion may be heard, before a conference dealing with the substantive issues in the case has been completed. The rule is designed to make the parties sit down with a judge before they begin exchanging affidavits.
The bar is not absolute. Under Rule 14(4.2), it does not apply where the Court is of the opinion that there is a situation of urgency or hardship, or that a case conference is not required for some other reason in the interest of justice. The Rules define neither urgency nor hardship. A party who brings a motion on the basis of an urgency the Court does not accept may be ordered to pay the costs of the wasted motion.
Rule 14(6) also lists eleven categories of motion to which the bar does not apply. Those most likely to arise in an ordinary family case are:
• A motion made without notice, made on consent, that is unopposed, or that is limited to procedural, uncomplicated, or unopposed matters (Form 14B).
• A contempt motion under Rule 31, or a motion to strike out a document under Rule 14(22).
• A motion for summary judgment under Rule 16.
• A motion to change a temporary order under Rule 25(19) for fraud, mistake, or lack of notice.
• A motion to require the Director of the Family Responsibility Office to refrain from suspending a licence.
• A motion to limit or stay a support order, the enforcement of support arrears, or an alternative payment order under the Family Responsibility and Support Arrears Enforcement Act, 1996.
The remaining categories concern child protection cases, appeals, requests for access to court files, certain oral hearings in arbitration and interjurisdictional support matters, and the registration of support orders made outside Canada.
What Must Be Filed, and When
Three sets of documents drive a case conference: the brief, the financial statement where support or property is in issue, and the confirmation of conference. Each has its own deadline.
The Case Conference Brief
Rule 17(13) requires each party to serve and file a case conference brief in Form 17A. Under Rule 17(13.1), the party who requested the conference must do so not later than six days before the conference date, and the other party not later than four days before. Where no party requested the conference, the six-day deadline falls on the applicant or the party making the motion.
Because each of these periods is shorter than seven days, Rule 3(2) excludes Saturdays, Sundays, and other days when court offices are closed, so the deadlines operate as business days. In the Superior Court of Justice, the Consolidated Provincial Practice Direction for Family Proceedings also limits a case conference brief to eight pages, including any appendix or schedule of facts or argument, plus certain permitted attachments. Documents must use at least 12-point font and double spacing. Regional and local practice directions add their own requirements and should always be checked.
The Financial Statement
Where support or property is in issue, the financial information before the Court must be current. Under Rule 13(12), a party must update their financial information if their last financial statement would be more than 60 days old by the time the case conference is held. Rule 13(12.1) sets out what the update looks like:
• If nothing has changed, an affidavit stating that the information in the last statement has not changed and is still true.
• If the changes are minor, an affidavit setting out the details of the changes.
• In any other case, a new financial statement (Form 13 or 13.1).
The update is due on the same six-day and four-day schedule as the brief. A certificate of financial disclosure (Form 13A) confirms which supporting documents have been served, and it must also be filed within those deadlines.
Under Rule 1.2, identifying financial account numbers and personal identification numbers, such as social insurance numbers and bank, credit card, and mortgage account numbers, must be redacted after service and before filing. The filing party keeps the complete, unredacted version and must have it available at every conference and hearing in case the judge asks to see it.
The Confirmation of Conference
Under Rule 17(14), each party must first give a copy of the confirmation of conference (Form 17F) to every other party, and then give it to the clerk not later than 2:00 p.m. three days before the conference date. Missing this step has a serious consequence. Under Rule 17(14.1), unless the Court orders otherwise, the conference is not held if the confirmation is not given. If anything in a confirmation becomes inaccurate before the conference, Rule 17(14.1.1) requires the party to deliver a corrected version.
Talking to the Other Side First
Rule 17(3.1) requires each party to confer, or make best efforts to confer, with every other party before a conference, either orally or in writing. Before a case conference, the discussion covers two subjects: each party’s requests for financial disclosure, and a temporary resolution of the issues in dispute.
Rule 17(3.2) sets out two exceptions: where a party is prohibited from such communication by court order, and where there is a risk of domestic violence by a party who is not represented by a licensed representative, meaning a lawyer or licensed paralegal. The obligation has teeth. Under Rule 17(3.3), failing to confer can lead to an order postponing the conference, an order for costs, or both.
Who Attends
Rule 17(15) requires the parties to attend unless the Court orders otherwise. Each represented party must also be accompanied by a licensed representative with full knowledge of and authority in the case.
A case conference is usually conducted by a judge, but not always. Under Rules 17(9) and 17(9.1), it may be conducted by a person whom the regional senior judge has named for that purpose. Eligible people include an Ontario lawyer with at least ten years of experience in family law, a retired lawyer who had ten years of family law experience at retirement, a master or retired master of the Superior Court of Justice (the office now titled associate judge), and a retired judge of that court. Any party may ask that the conference be held before a judge instead.
What the Judge Can Order
Although a case conference is not a hearing, the judge’s powers are real. Rule 17(8) permits seven kinds of order where appropriate:
• An order for document disclosure under Rule 19, questioning under Rule 20, or the filing of summaries of argument on a motion, along with directions or timetables for the next steps.
• An order about expert opinion evidence, covering the engagement of an expert, the use of expert evidence in the case, and the provision of reports.
• An order requiring the parties to file a trial management or trial scheduling endorsement.
• An order requiring attendance at a mandatory information program, a conference before a person named under Rule 17(9), an intake meeting with a court-affiliated mediation service, or another community program.
• Where notice has been served, a final order or any temporary order, including the preservation orders set out below.
• An unopposed order or an order on consent.
• On consent, a referral of any issue to alternative dispute resolution.
Rule 17(8)(b.1) names six temporary orders designed to preserve the parties’ rights until a further agreement or order is made. These can be especially valuable early in a case, when one party is concerned that assets may be moved or coverage cancelled:
• Orders relating to beneficiary designations under a life insurance policy, registered retirement savings plan, trust, pension, annuity, or similar financial instrument.
• Orders preserving assets generally or particularly.
• Orders prohibiting the concealment or destruction of documents or property.
• Orders requiring an accounting of funds under one party’s control.
• Orders preserving health and medical insurance coverage for a party and the children.
• Orders continuing periodic payments required to preserve an asset or benefit for a party and the children.
If an Agreement Is Reached
Under Rule 17(19), no agreement reached at a conference is effective until it is signed by the parties and witnessed and, in a case involving a special party or a child party, approved by the Court. Under Rule 17(20), the agreement is then filed as part of the continuing record unless the Court orders otherwise.
What Happens to the Brief Afterwards
Under Rule 17(22), case conference briefs do not form part of the continuing record unless the Court orders otherwise. They are returned to the parties who filed them at the end of the conference, or destroyed by court staff immediately afterward. If the Court does order a brief into the record, Rule 17(22.1) requires the portion dealing with settlement to be deleted.
One difference from a settlement conference is worth noting. Rule 17(24) prevents a judge who conducts a settlement conference from later hearing that issue, and Rule 17(23) keeps settlement conference briefs and statements from other judges. The Rules contain no equivalent protections for a case conference, so a brief should be prepared on the understanding that the same judge may hear later steps in the case.
When Costs Are Awarded
Rule 17(18) restricts the costs that can be awarded at a conference. Costs are not awarded unless a party:
• Was not prepared.
• Did not serve the required documents.
• Did not make any required disclosure.
• Otherwise contributed to the conference being unproductive.
• Otherwise did not follow the Rules.
Where one of these applies, the judge orders the party to pay the costs of the conference immediately, decides the amount, and gives any directions needed. Under Rule 17(18.1), costs that are not awarded at the conference can still be awarded at a later stage of the case.
What Comes After
Where issues remain after the case conference, the next step is usually a settlement conference. Rule 17(5) gives it nine purposes, including one that a case conference does not offer: obtaining, if possible, a view of how the Court might decide the case. Under Rule 17(10), a case is not scheduled for trial unless a settlement conference has been conducted or a judge has ordered the case scheduled.
Time also matters. Under the case management rules (Rule 39 in the Family Court of the Superior Court of Justice, Rule 40 in the Ontario Court of Justice, and Rule 41 in other Superior Court locations), the clerk serves a notice of approaching dismissal if a case has not been settled, withdrawn, or scheduled or adjourned for trial before the 365th day after it was started. The case is then dismissed without further notice unless, within 60 days of that notice, a party:
• Obtains an order lengthening the time.
• Files an agreement signed by all parties and their licensed representatives for a final order disposing of all issues, with a notice of motion for an order carrying out the agreement.
• Serves and files a notice of withdrawal discontinuing all outstanding claims.
• Schedules or adjourns the case for trial.
• Arranges a case conference or settlement conference for the first available date.
Where the issues concern parenting, Foote Law’s guide to child custody and parenting arrangements in Ontario explains how those decisions are made.
Have a Case Conference Coming Up?
A case conference turns on the brief, the disclosure, and whether the Rule 17 deadlines were met. It is the first opportunity to obtain a temporary order, and costs can be ordered against a party who arrives unprepared. Early legal advice makes a real difference to how the conference unfolds.
Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.
