Disclaimer
The information provided in this blog and the website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this blog does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
A marriage contract, often called a prenuptial agreement or “prenup,” allows spouses to decide in advance how property, support, and other affairs will be handled if the marriage ends. In Ontario, section 52(1) of the Family Law Act permits a marriage contract to address four categories: ownership or division of property, support obligations, the right to direct the education and moral training of the children, and any other matter in the settlement of the parties’ affairs.
That flexibility has firm limits. Whatever the contract says, it cannot determine decision-making responsibility or parenting time for the children, and it cannot limit either spouse’s right to possession of the matrimonial home. Even the terms a marriage contract may include remain open to review by a court in certain circumstances.
How Foote Law Can Help
Foote Law prepares and reviews marriage contracts for couples before and during marriage. Its services include:
• Advice on which entitlements are in play, and what a contract can and cannot change.
• Drafting the contract, including terms on property, support, and rights on death.
• Managing the exchange of financial disclosure and keeping a record of it.
• Independent legal advice where the other party’s lawyer prepared the contract.
• Review of a cohabitation agreement that marriage has converted into a marriage contract.
• Applications to set aside a contract, and responses to those applications.
Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, Centre Wellington, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.
What a Marriage Contract Is
Section 51 of the Family Law Act recognizes five kinds of domestic contract: a marriage contract, a separation agreement, a cohabitation agreement, a paternity agreement, and a family arbitration agreement. A marriage contract is the one that spouses, or people about to become spouses, use to plan for the future.
Under section 52(1), two persons who are married to each other or intend to marry may agree on their respective rights and obligations under the marriage, on separation, on the annulment or dissolution of the marriage, or on death. Timing does not change the nature of the document. A contract signed before the wedding and one signed years into the marriage are both marriage contracts under Ontario law.
A marriage contract can also come into being without the couple drafting one. Under section 53(2), if the parties to a cohabitation agreement marry each other, the agreement is deemed to be a marriage contract. The conversion is automatic, whether or not the couple expected to marry when they signed. From that point on, section 52 governs the agreement, and any provision limiting matrimonial home rights becomes unenforceable.
Changing How Property Is Divided
Section 52(1)(a) permits the parties to agree on ownership in or division of property, both during the marriage and when it ends. Without a contract, Ontario divides property on separation by equalizing net family property under Part I of the Act. In general terms, each spouse calculates the growth in their net worth over the marriage, and the spouse with the larger increase pays the other half the difference.
A marriage contract can displace that calculation. The statutory mechanism is paragraph 6 of section 4(2), which excludes from a spouse’s net family property anything the spouses have agreed by a domestic contract is not to be included.
Section 4(2) lists seven categories of property that do not form part of a spouse’s net family property:
• Property, other than a matrimonial home, acquired by gift or inheritance from a third person after the date of marriage.
• Income from that property, where the donor or testator expressly stated it was to be excluded.
• Damages or a right to damages for personal injuries, nervous shock, mental distress, or loss of guidance, care, and companionship, and the part of a settlement representing those damages.
• Proceeds or a right to proceeds of a policy of life insurance payable on the death of the life insured.
• Property, other than a matrimonial home, into which any of the above can be traced.
• Property that the spouses have agreed by a domestic contract is not to be included in a spouse’s net family property.
• Unadjusted pensionable earnings under the Canada Pension Plan.
Six of these exclusions apply automatically. Paragraph 6 is the only one the parties create themselves, and it is the tool used to protect a business interest, a professional practice, or property brought into the marriage. Under section 4(3), the spouse claiming an exclusion bears the burden of proving it, so clear records matter as much as clear drafting.
The Matrimonial Home
The matrimonial home receives special treatment. Section 52(2) separates the right to live in the home from the questions of who owns it and how its value is shared on separation.
What Cannot Be Limited
Under section 52(2), a provision in a marriage contract purporting to limit a spouse’s rights under Part II of the Act is unenforceable.
Part II gives both spouses an equal right to possession of the matrimonial home, regardless of whose name is on title. It also prevents either spouse from selling, mortgaging, or otherwise encumbering the home without the other spouse’s consent, subject to limited exceptions such as a court order. As a result, a spouse who owned the home before the marriage, and whose name alone appears on title, cannot use a marriage contract to exclude the other spouse from living there.
What Can Be Agreed
Section 52(2) protects possession, not ownership. A marriage contract can therefore determine who owns the home, how its value is treated on separation, whether the home or its value is excluded from an equalization claim, and whether one spouse has an option to purchase the other’s interest.
These terms carry particular weight because the home is treated differently even without a contract. The tracing exclusion in section 4(2) expressly excepts the matrimonial home. An inheritance kept separate stays excluded; the same money put into the matrimonial home loses that protection unless a marriage contract preserves it.
Can Spouses Agree on Spousal Support?
Section 52(1)(b) permits the parties to agree on support obligations, including the amount, the duration, or a complete waiver of the right to support. Those terms are not beyond review. Under section 33(4), a court may set aside a support provision or a waiver and order support, even where the contract expressly excludes that section. There are three grounds:
• The provision for support, or the waiver, results in unconscionable circumstances.
• The provision is in favour of, or the waiver is by or on behalf of, a dependant who qualifies for an allowance for support out of public money.
• There is default in the payment of support under the contract when the application is made.
The second ground means spouses cannot use a waiver to shift the cost of supporting a dependant onto public assistance. The first ground looks at the circumstances when the application is brought, not when the contract was signed. A waiver that was reasonable at signing can therefore still be set aside if life has changed significantly since.
What a Marriage Contract Does on Death
Section 52(1) also permits a marriage contract to deal with rights and obligations on death. When a married spouse dies in Ontario, the surviving spouse must choose between an equalization payment under Part I of the Act and what the will provides or, where there is no will, what the intestacy rules under the Succession Law Reform Act provide. A marriage contract can address that entitlement in advance. It should be drafted alongside both spouses’ wills so that the documents work together rather than contradict each other.
What a Marriage Contract Can Say About Children
Section 52(1)(c) permits one subject concerning children and prohibits another. The parties may agree on the right to direct the education and moral training of their children, such as schooling or religious upbringing. They may not agree on decision-making responsibility or parenting time.
Even the permitted subject remains open to review. Under section 56(1), when a court determines a matter respecting the education, moral training, decision-making responsibility, or parenting time of a child, it may disregard any provision of a domestic contract on that matter where doing so is in the best interests of the child.
Child support is treated the same way. Under section 56(1.1), a court may disregard a child support provision that is unreasonable having regard to the child support guidelines and to any other provision in the contract relating to the child’s support. Child support belongs to the child, and parents cannot bargain it away.
What a Marriage Contract Cannot Settle
Four subjects fall outside what a marriage contract can finally settle:
• Decision-making responsibility and parenting time, under section 52(1)(c).
• A spouse’s right to possession of the matrimonial home, and the consent requirement before the home is sold or encumbered, under section 52(2).
• Child support at a level the court considers unreasonable against the guidelines, under section 56(1.1).
• A provision about education or moral training that the court finds contrary to the child’s best interests, under section 56(1).
The consequence differs by provision. A term limiting matrimonial home rights is unenforceable under section 52(2) in every case. A term about children or child support is one the court may disregard under sections 56(1) and 56(1.1), depending on the child’s best interests and the guidelines.
When a Marriage Contract Can Be Set Aside
A marriage contract that stays within section 52 can still fail, either because it was not properly signed or because of how it was negotiated.
The Form Requirements
Under section 55(1), a domestic contract, and any agreement to amend or rescind one, is unenforceable unless it is made in writing, signed by the parties, and witnessed. An oral promise does not qualify, and neither does an unsigned draft or an informal agreement to change the terms later.
The Three Grounds
Under section 56(4), a court may, on application, set aside a domestic contract or a provision in it:
• If a party failed to disclose to the other significant assets, or significant debts or other liabilities, existing when the domestic contract was made.
• If a party did not understand the nature or consequences of the domestic contract.
• Otherwise in accordance with the law of contract.
The third ground brings in the ordinary doctrines of contract law, including unconscionability, undue influence, mistake, duress, misrepresentation, and repudiation. Under section 56(7), these grounds apply despite any agreement to the contrary, so a contract cannot waive them.
Setting aside a contract is a two-stage process. First, the party seeking to set it aside must prove that one of the three circumstances exists. Proving a ground does not automatically void the contract. The court then decides, based on all the circumstances, whether setting it aside is appropriate.
Full, documented financial disclosure before signing is the most effective protection against a challenge on the first ground. Independent legal advice plays a similar role on the second. It is not a statutory requirement in Ontario, and a contract does not fail for lack of it. A party who received advice on the nature and consequences of the contract, however, will find it much harder to claim later that they did not understand what they signed.
For couples who are not married, Foote Law’s guide to what should be included in a cohabitation agreement in Ontario explains how those agreements differ.
Thinking About a Marriage Contract?
A marriage contract is only as strong as the disclosure behind it, the advice each spouse received, and its compliance with the form requirements in section 55(1). Early legal advice, ideally well before any wedding date, gives both parties time to negotiate fairly and reduces the risk of a later challenge.
Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.
