Orangeville: (519) 940 - 8309
Fergus: (519) 772-6139
Fax: (519) 940 - 0526

Marriage Contract vs. Prenuptial Agreement in Ontario: What Is the Difference?

There is no difference. The Family Law Act does not use the term “prenuptial agreement”; it calls the document a Marriage Contract, and Part IV of that Act sets out who can make one, what it can decide, and when a court can set it aside.

What matters is not the name but the reach. The Act limits what a Marriage Contract can do, and one of those limits concerns the matrimonial home.

How Foote Law Can Help

Foote Law prepares and reviews Marriage Contracts, and advises on the enforceability of agreements already signed. Services include:

  • Advice on whether a Marriage Contract, a cohabitation agreement, or a separation agreement is the right instrument.
  • Drafting and execution of a Marriage Contract that meets the requirements of section 55(1).
  • Advice on excluding specific property, including a home owned before the marriage or an interest in a business, from net family property.
  • Financial disclosure, and the record of it that the agreement should carry.
  • Independent legal advice for a party presented with an agreement drafted by the other side’s lawyer.
  • Review of an existing agreement, including one signed in another country or within a religious tradition, against the requirements of the Act.
  • Applications to set aside a domestic contract, and the defence of one.

Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, Centre Wellington, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.

Why the Family Law Act Has No Prenuptial Agreement

Part IV of the Family Law Act is titled Domestic Contracts, and section 51 defines a domestic contract as a Marriage Contract, separation agreement, cohabitation agreement, paternity agreement, or family arbitration agreement. Three of them have their own sections:

  • A Marriage Contract, under section 52.
  • A cohabitation agreement, under section 53.
  • A separation agreement, under section 54.

“Prenup” and “postnup” are ordinary speech, not categories in the Act. A document headed “Prenuptial Agreement” is still a Marriage Contract if it meets section 52, and sections 55 and 56 apply to it as they would if it were headed “Marriage Contract.” The title on the cover page changes nothing.

Before the Wedding or After It

Section 52(1) allows a Marriage Contract to be made by two persons who are married to each other or who intend to marry. Both timings fall under the same section, so what people call a postnuptial agreement is governed by the same provision as what they call a prenuptial agreement.

Section 52(1) also allows a Marriage Contract to deal with rights and obligations on separation. A separation agreement is a different instrument: under section 54, two persons who cohabited and are living separate and apart may enter into an agreement about their respective rights and obligations. Foote Law’s guide to separation agreements in Ontario covers that document.

What the Act Provides Without a Marriage Contract

Section 2(10) provides that a domestic contract dealing with a matter that is also dealt with in the Act prevails unless the Act provides otherwise. The value of a Marriage Contract therefore depends on what the Act’s default rules are.

Part I of the Act provides for the equalization of net family property. Under section 4(1), a spouse’s net family property is the value of the property the spouse owns on the valuation date, after deducting the spouse’s debts and other liabilities and the value of property, other than a matrimonial home, that the spouse owned on the date of the marriage. Section 4(2) then excludes seven categories of property.

Under section 5(1), when a divorce is granted, a marriage is declared a nullity, or the spouses are separated with no reasonable prospect of resuming cohabitation, the spouse with the lesser net family property is entitled to one-half the difference between the two.

The matrimonial home is treated differently. The deduction in section 4(1) for property owned on the date of the marriage does not apply to a matrimonial home, so a spouse who owned the home when the marriage began deducts nothing for its value. Under Part II, section 19(1) gives both spouses an equal right to possession of a matrimonial home. Foote Law’s family law services cover property-related issues arising during separation.

What a Marriage Contract Can Decide

Under section 52(1), a Marriage Contract can settle the parties’ respective rights and obligations under the marriage, on separation, on the annulment or dissolution of the marriage, or on death. The section names four subjects:

  • Ownership in or division of property.
  • Support obligations.
  • The right to direct the education and moral training of their children, but not the right to decision-making responsibility or parenting time.
  • Any other matter in the settlement of their affairs.

What a Marriage Contract Cannot Decide

Four areas are limited by the Act, whatever the document says.

Decision-Making Responsibility and Parenting Time

Section 52(1)(c) permits agreement on the education and moral training of the children but not on decision-making responsibility or parenting time. A separation agreement under section 54, by contrast, may address both.

Even on education and moral training, section 56(1) allows a court to disregard a provision of a domestic contract pertaining to a matter respecting the education, moral training, decision-making responsibility, or parenting time of a child where, in the opinion of the court, doing so is in the best interests of the child.

Child Support

A Marriage Contract can contain a provision about child support, but section 56(1.1) allows a court to disregard it where the provision is unreasonable having regard to the child support guidelines, as well as to any other provision relating to the support of the child in the contract. The provision is not prohibited; the court is simply not bound by it.

The Matrimonial Home

Section 52(2) provides that a provision in a Marriage Contract purporting to limit a spouse’s rights under Part II of the Act, the part dealing with the matrimonial home, is unenforceable. Section 19(1) gives both spouses an equal right to possession of a matrimonial home, and a Marriage Contract cannot limit that right or the other rights in Part II.

Conduct and Fidelity Clauses

Under section 56(2), a provision in a domestic contract to take effect on separation whereby any right of a party is dependent upon that party remaining chaste is unenforceable. The subsection does not affect a contingency upon marriage or cohabitation with another.

Property Rules a Marriage Contract Can Change

Section 52(2) is directed at provisions that limit a spouse’s rights under Part II. Section 52(1)(a) separately permits agreement on ownership in or division of property.

Section 4(2) lists seven categories of property excluded from a spouse’s net family property. Paragraph 1, which covers property other than a matrimonial home acquired by gift or inheritance from a third person after the date of the marriage, and paragraph 5, which covers property other than a matrimonial home into which that property can be traced, both leave the matrimonial home outside their reach. Paragraph 6, which excludes property that the spouses have agreed by a domestic contract is not to be included in net family property, contains no such exception.

The practical effect is that an inheritance traced into a matrimonial home is not excluded by paragraphs 1 or 5, while a Marriage Contract can provide under paragraph 6 that the same property is not to be included. Paragraph 6 is not limited to a home: spouses may also agree that other property, such as an interest in a business, is not to be included.

Waiving Spousal Support

Support obligations are among the subjects that section 52(1) permits, so a Marriage Contract can address spousal support, and section 2(10) gives the contract priority over the Act’s default rules unless the Act provides otherwise.

Section 33(4) allows a court to set aside a provision for support or a waiver of the right to support in a domestic contract, even though the contract excludes the application of that section, on three grounds: where the provision or waiver results in unconscionable circumstances; where the provision is in favour of, or the waiver is by or on behalf of, a dependant who qualifies for an allowance for support out of public money; or where there is default in the payment of support under the contract at the time the application is made.

What Makes a Marriage Contract Enforceable

Section 55(1) provides that a domestic contract, and an agreement to amend or rescind a domestic contract, is unenforceable unless made in writing, signed by the parties, and witnessed. Section 35(1) allows a party to file a domestic contract with the court but does not require it.

Financial disclosure is not among the formalities in section 55(1). It matters for a different reason: section 56(4)(a) allows a court to set a contract aside where a party failed to disclose significant assets, or significant debts or other liabilities.

Whether Both Parties Need Their Own Lawyer

The Act does not require a lawyer. Nothing in section 55(1) or section 56 makes legal advice a condition of enforceability.

Rule 3.4-5 of the Law Society of Ontario’s Rules of Professional Conduct requires a lawyer who acts for more than one client in a matter to advise each client that the lawyer has been asked to act for both or all of them, that no information received from one client can be treated as confidential from the others, and that if a conflict develops that cannot be resolved, the lawyer cannot continue to act for both or all of them and may have to withdraw completely.

Because the parties to a Marriage Contract generally have opposed financial interests, the usual arrangement is that one lawyer drafts the agreement for the party who instructed that lawyer, and the other party takes advice from a separate lawyer, who reviews the agreement and signs a certificate recording that advice was given.

An Agreement That Does Not Meet the Formalities

An agreement that was never witnessed, or that only one party signed, is unenforceable as a domestic contract under section 55(1). It does not follow that it has no effect.

Section 5(6) allows a court to award a spouse more or less than half the difference between the net family properties if equalizing them would be unconscionable, having regard to the matters listed in that subsection. One of those matters, in clause 5(6)(g), is a written agreement between the spouses that is not a domestic contract. A defective agreement can therefore be considered in the division of property, although the court is not bound by its terms.

When a Court Can Set a Marriage Contract Aside

Section 56(4) allows a court, on application, to set aside a domestic contract or a provision in it:

  • Where a party failed to disclose to the other significant assets, or significant debts or other liabilities, existing when the domestic contract was made.
  • Where a party did not understand the nature or consequences of the domestic contract.
  • Otherwise in accordance with the law of contract.

Both limits in the first ground matter: the undisclosed asset, debt, or liability must be significant, and it must have existed when the contract was made, so property acquired later is not caught by it.

Section 56(4) provides that a court may set a contract aside on these grounds; it does not require the court to do so. The Act also sets no minimum period between the signing of a Marriage Contract and the wedding.

A Cohabitation Agreement That Becomes a Marriage Contract

Section 53(2) provides that if the parties to a cohabitation agreement marry each other, the agreement is deemed to be a Marriage Contract. No new document is required for that to occur.

Marriage brings the equalization of net family property under Part I and the matrimonial home provisions under Part II into play, and section 52(2) then applies to the deemed Marriage Contract. Foote Law’s guide to cohabitation agreements in Ontario sets out what the document covers before marriage.

What a Marriage Contract Does on Death

Section 52(1) allows a Marriage Contract to deal with the parties’ rights and obligations on death. Two statutory claims warrant care.

The first is the surviving spouse’s election under section 6 of the Family Law Act to receive the entitlement under section 5 instead of taking under the will or on an intestacy. Under section 6(10), the election must be filed within six months after the first spouse’s death.

The second is a dependant support claim under Part V of the Succession Law Reform Act. Under section 63(4), an order for the support of a dependant may be made despite any agreement or waiver to the contrary, and section 62(1)(m) lists any agreement between the deceased and the dependant among the circumstances the court considers. A release therefore does not necessarily close the door. Foote Law’s guide to dying without a will in Ontario sets out how an estate is distributed where no will applies.

Changing or Ending a Marriage Contract

Section 55(1) applies to an agreement to amend or rescind a domestic contract in the same terms as it applies to the contract itself, so a change must be made in writing, signed by the parties, and witnessed. An agreement to amend that is not made in that way is unenforceable.

The Act sets no expiry date for a Marriage Contract and does not require it to be reviewed. Parties whose circumstances have changed materially should consider an amendment made in accordance with section 55(1).

Considering a Marriage Contract?

A Marriage Contract decides who keeps what and who pays what, and the Act gives it priority over its own default rules unless the Act provides otherwise. Early legal advice, obtained before the wedding or at any point during the marriage, allows time for financial disclosure and for each party to receive advice. Foote Law drafts Marriage Contracts, provides independent legal advice to a party asked to sign one, and reviews agreements already in place.

Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.

Book a Consultation

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D.

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D. is a Barrister and Solicitor and the Founder of Foote Law in Orangeville, Ontario. She earned her Juris Doctor from Osgoode Hall Law School and her Honours Bachelor of Business Administration and Management from the University of Guelph. Her legal experience includes family law, criminal law, real estate, and wills and estates. Jessica is committed to providing approachable, client-focused legal guidance and helping individuals and families understand their legal options. She is also actively involved in legal education, professional organisations, and community initiatives throughout Dufferin County and the surrounding areas.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.