Orangeville: (519) 940 - 8309
Fergus: (519) 772-6139
Fax: (519) 940 - 0526

What Happens to the Matrimonial Home After Separation in Ontario

Neither spouse has to leave the matrimonial home on separation, and neither can make the other leave. Section 19(1) of the Family Law Act gives both spouses an equal right to possession, and that right does not depend on whose name is on title.

What changes that is a court order, an agreement, or a sale. Each runs on its own rules, and the home is treated differently from every other asset in the division of property.

Request a Consultation

What Makes a Home the Matrimonial Home

Section 18 defines it by use rather than by ownership. Property in which a person has an interest and which the spouses ordinarily occupied as their family residence at the time of separation is a matrimonial home. Three points follow from the section:

  • A share in a corporation that entitles the owner to occupy a unit owned by that corporation counts as an interest in the unit, which brings most co-operative housing within the definition.
  • Where property is used mainly for purposes other than residence, only the part reasonably necessary for the residential use is the matrimonial home.
  • Because the test is ordinary occupation as a family residence, a cottage or second property the family ordinarily used can also be a matrimonial home.

Section 20 allows one or both spouses to designate property as the matrimonial home in the prescribed form, and to register the designation in the land registry office. A designation made by both spouses ends matrimonial home status for other property; a designation by one spouse alone does not.

Both Spouses Have an Equal Right to Possession

Section 19(1) provides that both spouses have an equal right to possession of a matrimonial home. A spouse who holds title alone cannot change the locks, cannot require the other to leave, and cannot treat the other’s continued occupation as trespass.

Section 19(2) sets the limit of that right where only one spouse has an interest in the property. The other spouse’s right of possession is personal against that spouse, and it ends when they cease to be spouses, unless a separation agreement or a court order provides otherwise.

Neither Spouse Can Sell or Mortgage It Alone

Under section 21(1), a spouse may not dispose of or encumber an interest in a matrimonial home unless the other spouse joins in the instrument or consents, has released the right by separation agreement, a court order has authorised the transaction, or another property has been validly designated as the matrimonial home.

Section 21(2) allows a transaction made in contravention of that to be set aside, unless the person who acquired the interest did so for value, in good faith, and without notice that the property was a matrimonial home.

Where consent is withheld, section 23 is the route. On the application of a spouse or an interested person the court may:

  • Determine whether property is a matrimonial home and, if so, its extent.
  • Authorise a disposition or encumbrance where the spouse whose consent is required cannot be found, is unavailable, is incapable of consenting, or is unreasonably withholding consent.
  • Dispense with the notice required under section 22.
  • Set aside a transaction that contravened section 21(1) and order the interest revested.
  • Cancel a designation where the property is not a matrimonial home.

How the Value Is Divided

Property division runs on the valuation date, which section 4(1) defines as the earliest of five dates:

  • The date the spouses separate and there is no reasonable prospect that they will resume cohabitation.
  • The date a divorce is granted.
  • The date the marriage is declared a nullity.
  • The date one of the spouses commences an application based on subsection 5(3), improvident depletion, that is subsequently granted.
  • The date before the date on which one of the spouses dies leaving the other spouse surviving.

The home is then treated differently from every other asset, in two ways that work in the same direction.

Net family property, as defined in section 4(1), deducts the value of property the spouse owned on the date of the marriage, but expressly not a matrimonial home. A spouse who owned the home when the marriage began includes its full valuation-date value and deducts nothing for it.

The exclusions in section 4(2) carry the same carve-out. Paragraph 1 excludes property acquired by gift or inheritance from a third person after the marriage, other than a matrimonial home. Paragraph 5 excludes property into which such property can be traced, again other than a matrimonial home. An inheritance put into the home therefore loses its exclusion.

Under section 5(1) the spouse whose net family property is the lower of the two is entitled to half the difference. Learn more about Foote Law’s family law services, including property division and equalization.

Exclusive Possession of the Home

Section 24(1) allows the court, regardless of ownership and despite section 19, to make an order on application. Its powers include:

  • Directing that the home and its contents be kept in safe custody.
  • Granting one spouse exclusive possession of the home or part of it for a specified period.
  • Directing a spouse to whom exclusive possession is granted to make periodic payments to the other spouse.
  • Directing that the contents of the home be used or removed by one spouse.
  • Directing a spouse to pay for repairs and maintenance, or other liabilities of the home.
  • Authorising a disposition or encumbrance subject to the other spouse’s right of exclusive possession.
  • Where a false statement was made under subsection 21(3), directing the substitution of other property or the delivery of security.

Section 24(2) allows a temporary or interim order on motion. Section 24(3) requires the court, in deciding exclusive possession, to consider six matters:

  • The best interests of the children affected.
  • Any existing orders under Part I, family property, and any existing support orders.
  • The financial position of both spouses.
  • Any written agreement between the parties.
  • The availability of other suitable and affordable accommodation.
  • Any violence committed by a spouse against the other spouse or the children.

In assessing a child’s best interests under section 24(4), the court considers the possible disruptive effects of a move and the child’s views and preferences where they can reasonably be ascertained.

Where there has been violence, a restraining order under section 46 may be sought alongside or instead of exclusive possession. Read more about restraining orders and protection orders in Ontario.

What Happens If an Exclusive Possession Order Is Broken

Contravening an order for exclusive possession is an offence under section 24(5). On a first offence the penalty is a fine of not more than $5,000 or imprisonment for not more than three months, or both. On a second or subsequent offence it is a fine of not more than $10,000 or imprisonment for not more than two years, or both.

Section 24(6) makes the order enforceable without a further court step: a police officer may arrest without warrant a person the officer believes on reasonable and probable grounds has contravened it. An agreement between the spouses carries no such power, which is the practical difference between an agreement and an order.

Who Pays the Mortgage in the Meantime

The Act sets no default rule. Where an order for exclusive possession is made, section 24(1) gives the court two tools: it may direct the spouse in possession to make periodic payments to the other, and it may direct either spouse to pay for repairs, maintenance and other liabilities of the home.

Absent an order, payments continue to be governed by the mortgage itself, which binds whoever covenanted to pay regardless of who is living there. A spouse who stops paying exposes their own credit and the equity both spouses will divide.

Occupation Rent

Where one spouse remains in the home and the other does not, the spouse who left may claim occupation rent. It is a discretionary remedy, awarded where the court considers it reasonable and equitable, and the Court of Appeal for Ontario held in 2023 that such claims are no longer restricted to exceptional cases.

The matters weighed include:

  • The timing of the claim and the length of the occupation.
  • Whether the spouse who left was unable to access their equity in the property.
  • Whether that spouse sought a sale.
  • Whether the occupying spouse paid the mortgage and the carrying costs.
  • Whether children live in the home.
  • Whether the occupying spouse increased the value of the property.

Mortgage and carrying costs paid by the occupying spouse weigh against an award. Where the equities have already been addressed, through a post-separation adjustment or a finding of beneficial ownership, the court may decline occupation rent on the basis that the spouse who left has already been compensated.

Forcing a Sale

Where both spouses are on title, section 2 of the Partition Act provides that joint tenants and tenants in common may be compelled to make or suffer partition or sale of the land. Under section 3(1), any person interested in land in Ontario may bring an action or application for partition, or for sale under the direction of the court where the court considers a sale more advantageous to the parties interested. Section 3(2) bars any proceeding until one year after the death where the land was held jointly by reason of a devise or an intestacy.

A co-owner has a prima facie right to partition or sale. It is refused where the party opposing establishes that the applicant’s conduct is malicious, vexatious or oppressive, and the onus of proving that rests on the party opposing the sale.

Family law overlays that right. The Court of Appeal has held that a partition application should not proceed where it would prejudice either spouse’s rights under the Family Law Act, and that interim orders for sale are not made as a matter of course.

When sale is ordered before the property claims are resolved, the proceeds may be held in trust so that they remain available to satisfy an equalization payment. The best interests of the children are a primary consideration, and the presence of children alone is not enough; the party opposing must show an effect more serious than the disruption separation ordinarily brings.

Where only one spouse owns the home the Partition Act has no application. The owner cannot sell without the other spouse’s consent because of section 21, and the route is an application under section 23 for authorisation where consent is being unreasonably withheld.

The Deadline for an Equalization Claim

Section 7(3) requires an application for an equalization payment to be brought by the earliest of:

  • Two years after the day the marriage is terminated by divorce or judgment of nullity.
  • Six years after the day the spouses separate and there is no reasonable prospect that they will resume cohabitation.
  • Six months after the first spouse’s death.

The six-year period runs from separation, not from the date a divorce is started, so a couple who separate and do not divorce still face a deadline.

Common-Law Partners and the Home

Part II applies to spouses as section 1(1) defines them: either of two persons who are married to each other, or who have together entered into a marriage that is voidable or void, in good faith on the part of the person relying on the definition to assert a right. The extended definition that brings in unmarried partners sits in Part III and governs support obligations, not the home.

An unmarried partner therefore has no equal right of possession under section 19, cannot apply for exclusive possession under section 24, and is not protected by the consent requirement in section 21. Two routes remain. A partner who contributed to the property may advance a trust claim or a claim in unjust enrichment, and a partner who is on title may apply under the Partition Act in the same way as any other co-owner. Foote Law’s guide to cohabitation agreements in Ontario sets out how the position can be fixed in advance.

If a Spouse Dies

Section 26(1) addresses a matrimonial home held in joint tenancy with a third person rather than with the other spouse. The joint tenancy is deemed to have been severed immediately before the death, so the deceased spouse’s share falls into the estate rather than passing to the third person by survivorship.

Section 26(2) protects a spouse who has no interest in the home. A spouse

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D.

Jessica K. Foote, B.B.A. (Hons.), J.D. is a Barrister and Solicitor and the Founder of Foote Law in Orangeville, Ontario. She earned her Juris Doctor from Osgoode Hall Law School and her Honours Bachelor of Business Administration and Management from the University of Guelph. Her legal experience includes family law, criminal law, real estate, and wills and estates. Jessica is committed to providing approachable, client-focused legal guidance and helping individuals and families understand their legal options. She is also actively involved in legal education, professional organisations, and community initiatives throughout Dufferin County and the surrounding areas.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.