A Cohabitation Agreement and a Marriage Contract are closely related. Both are domestic contracts under the Family Law Act, and both can cover the same four subjects. The difference lies in the starting point. Married spouses have a statutory property regime, and a Marriage Contract can change how it applies to them. Unmarried partners in Ontario have no automatic property-sharing regime, so a Cohabitation Agreement creates rules where the default would otherwise be a court claim brought after the relationship has already ended.
A Marriage Contract is not limited to couples planning a wedding: section 52(1) also allows two persons who are already married to enter into one, so a couple can opt out of parts of the statutory regime after the wedding as well as before it, with the exception that a provision limiting a spouse’s matrimonial home rights under Part II is unenforceable under section 52(2). Section 53(1) of the Family Law Act permits a Cohabitation Agreement, and under section 53(2) it is deemed to be a Marriage Contract if the parties later marry.
How Foote Law Can Help
Foote Law prepares and reviews Cohabitation Agreements and Marriage Contracts for couples who are living together, planning to marry, or already married. Services include:
- Advice on what the default law gives each partner, and what the agreement changes.
- Drafting of the agreement and the disclosure schedules.
- Exchange of financial disclosure and the record of it.
- Independent legal advice and a certificate where the other partner’s lawyer prepared the agreement.
- Review of the agreement before marriage, because it becomes a Marriage Contract on the wedding.
- Marriage Contracts, whether signed before or after the wedding, for couples who want to change how the statutory property regime applies to them.
- Applications to set an agreement aside, and responses to them.
Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139. Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Fergus, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, Centre Wellington, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.
What the Law Provides Without an Agreement
Property
Part I of the Family Law Act, which provides for the equalization of net family property, applies to married spouses only. No period of cohabitation creates an automatic property right, and ten years together does not produce one. A partner seeking a share of property registered in the other’s name must bring a claim in unjust enrichment. Three elements must be established:
- An enrichment of the other partner.
- A corresponding deprivation of the partner bringing the claim.
- The absence of a juristic reason for the enrichment.
Where the relationship operated as a joint family venture, a constructive trust may be available over specific property. These claims are fact-heavy, expensive, and uncertain in outcome. Avoiding one is the practical purpose of the agreement.
Support
Section 29 brings unmarried partners into Part III of the Act for support purposes. A partner qualifies as a spouse where they have cohabited continuously for not less than three years, or are in a relationship of some permanence and are the parents of a child as set out in section 4 of the Children’s Law Reform Act. Meeting the section 29 definition does not carry over into the other Parts of the Act: a partner who qualifies for support under Part III does not thereby acquire rights under Part I or Part II.
The Family Home
Section 24 of the Family Law Act, which governs exclusive possession of the matrimonial home, sits in Part II and is available to married spouses only. Two other provisions are relevant to an unmarried partner:
- Section 34(1)(d) of the Family Law Act, which allows the court, on a support application under section 33, to make orders respecting the matters described in section 24(1)(a) to (e) (matrimonial home).
- Section 46(1) of the Family Law Act and section 35(1) of the Children’s Law Reform Act, which allow the court to make a restraining order where the applicant has reasonable grounds to fear for their own safety or the safety of a child in their lawful custody. Under section 46(2), a restraining order under the Family Law Act may be made against a person who is cohabiting, or has cohabited, with the applicant.
On Death
Under the Succession Law Reform Act, intestacy, which is the distribution of an estate where the deceased left no will, uses the married-only definition of spouse. A surviving common-law partner inherits nothing in that situation, regardless of the length of the relationship.
Part V of that Act, which governs claims by dependants against an estate, is different. Dependant support uses the broader section 29 meaning, so a surviving partner may apply for support from the estate where the deceased did not make adequate provision for them.
What a Cohabitation Agreement Can Cover
Section 53(1) permits two persons who are cohabiting or intend to cohabit, and who are not married to each other, to agree on their respective rights and obligations during cohabitation, on ceasing to cohabit, or on death, including:
- Ownership in or division of property.
- Support obligations.
- The right to direct the education and moral training of their children, but not the right to decision-making responsibility or parenting time.
- Any other matter in the settlement of their affairs.
The fourth subject carries most of the practical content: how household expenses are shared, how joint accounts operate, who is responsible for which debts, and what happens to property one partner brought into the relationship.
Property and the Family Home
Section 52(2) makes any provision limiting a spouse’s rights under Part II (Matrimonial Home) unenforceable, but it applies to Marriage Contracts only. An unmarried couple has no Part II rights to limit. Their agreement can determine who owns the home, how any increase in its value is treated, what happens to a partner’s contributions to the mortgage or renovations, and whether one partner may buy out the other.
Two situations produce most of the disputes:
- One partner owns the home and the other contributes to the mortgage, the taxes, or renovations without going on title.
- Both partners are on title but contributed unequally to the purchase.
In each case, without an agreement, the question is resolved by a trust claim after separation.
Support
A Cohabitation Agreement can set the amount and duration of spousal support, or waive it entirely. That waiver is not final. Under section 33(4), a court may set aside a support provision or a waiver and order support, even where the contract expressly excludes the section, on three grounds:
- The provision or waiver results in unconscionable circumstances.
- The provision is in favour of, or the waiver is by or on behalf of, a dependant who qualifies for an allowance for support out of public money.
- There is default in payment of support under the contract when the application is made.
Unconscionability is assessed on the circumstances when the application is brought. A waiver that was reasonable at signing can still be set aside years later.
Children
Section 53(1)(c) permits agreement on the right to direct the education and moral training of the children, and prohibits agreement on decision-making responsibility or parenting time. Under section 56(1), the court may disregard any provision of a domestic contract respecting education, moral training, decision-making responsibility or parenting time where doing so is in the best interests of the child.
Under section 56(1.1), the court may disregard a provision respecting child support where it is unreasonable having regard to the child support guidelines.
Child support and parenting obligations arise from parenthood, not from the length of the relationship. A couple who have a child together are subject to them from the outset, whether they have cohabited for one year or ten.
What Happens on Marriage
Under section 53(2), where the parties to a Cohabitation Agreement marry each other, the agreement is deemed to be a Marriage Contract. This happens automatically, whether or not the parties contemplated marrying when they signed.
The terms carry forward, with one exception. Section 52(2) now applies, so any provision limiting rights to the matrimonial home becomes unenforceable at the moment of marriage. A clause that governed the home during cohabitation may stop governing it on the wedding day.
An agreement should be reviewed before marriage rather than after.
Making the Agreement Hold Up
Section 55(1) provides that a domestic contract, and an agreement to amend or rescind one, are unenforceable unless:
- Made in writing.
- Signed by the parties.
- Witnessed.
The witness must sign. An oral agreement about property or support between partners is not enforceable as a domestic contract.
Under section 56(4), a court may set aside a contract that meets those requirements:
- If a party failed to disclose to the other significant assets, or significant debts or other liabilities, existing when the contract was made.
- If a party did not understand the nature or consequences of the contract.
- Otherwise in accordance with the law of contract, which carries unconscionability, undue influence, mistake, repudiation, duress, and misrepresentation.
The party seeking to set the contract aside must establish one of the three circumstances and carries the onus. Establishing a ground does not make the contract a nullity; the court then decides whether to set it aside.
Independent legal advice is not a statutory requirement. It is evidence on the second ground, because a party who was advised on what they were signing is in a weaker position to say afterward that they did not understand it.
Foote Law’s guide to what can you include in a Marriage Contract in Ontario sets out how the subjects differ once a couple marries.
Thinking About a Cohabitation Agreement?
Without an agreement, an unmarried partner’s property claim is an unjust enrichment case brought after separation, and a surviving partner inherits nothing on an intestacy. An agreement decides those questions in advance. Early legal advice, obtained before problems arise, gives both partners the widest range of choices.
Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309 or in Fergus at 519-772-6139.
