Orangeville: (519) 940 - 8309
Fergus: (519) 772-6139
Fax: (519) 940 - 0526

Bail Hearings in Ontario

When a person is arrested and held in custody, the bail hearing is one of the first and most urgent steps in a criminal case. It decides whether the accused remains in the community while the case moves through court, or waits in custody until it is resolved.

A bail hearing is not a trial and does not address guilt. Under Canadian law, an accused person is presumed innocent, and the starting point set out in the Criminal Code is release, not detention.

Foote Law represents people at bail hearings in Orangeville and across Ontario. The hours before a hearing matter, and early advice from a lawyer helps in preparing the plan that gives an accused the best chance of release.

How Foote Law Can Help

When an arrest leads to a bail hearing, Foote Law provides focused representation at every stage:

  • Preparation of a realistic release plan before the hearing
  • Advice for a proposed surety on what the role involves
  • Representation at the bail hearing itself
  • Negotiation with the Crown for release on the least restrictive terms
  • A bail review in the Superior Court if bail is denied
  • A variation of conditions if the ones imposed prove unworkable

Where We Serve

Foote Law accepts Legal Aid Ontario certificates and Employee Assistance Program referrals. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309.

Foote Law serves clients in Orangeville, Brampton, Shelburne, Alliston, Barrie, Owen Sound, Newmarket, Guelph, and throughout the Greater Toronto Area, in person and virtually.

What a Bail Hearing Is

A bail hearing, formally called judicial interim release, is the court process that decides whether an accused person is released while a charge proceeds. Under section 503 of the Criminal Code, police who do not release an accused after arrest must bring the person before a justice without unreasonable delay and, in any event, within 24 hours of the arrest if a justice is available.

Two points about timing are worth knowing:

  • Where the parties are ready to proceed, the hearing should happen the same day, including on weekends and holidays, when weekend bail court sits
  • If the hearing is adjourned while the accused is in custody, section 516 of the Criminal Code generally does not allow it to be put off for more than three clear days without the accused's consent

The Three Grounds, the Ladder
& Who Has to Prove What

01

The Three Grounds for Detention

Under section 515(10) of the Criminal Code, the court can refuse bail only on one or more of three grounds:

  • The primary ground: to make sure the accused attends court
  • The secondary ground: to protect the public, including any risk of reoffending or interfering with witnesses
  • The tertiary ground: to maintain public confidence in the administration of justice, which looks at the seriousness of the charge, the strength of the case, and the likely sentence

If none of these grounds is established, the accused is entitled to release.

02

Release or Detention: The Ladder

The Criminal Code requires the court to start at the least restrictive form of release and move up only as far as necessary. That order, often called the ladder principle, runs from a simple promise to attend court, to release with conditions, to release with a surety, to a deposit of money, with detention held as a last resort.

A defence lawyer's job is to keep an accused as low on that ladder as the circumstances allow, since the law prefers release on the least restrictive terms that fit the case.

03

Who Has to Prove What

In most cases, the Crown must show why an accused should be detained or held on strict terms; the accused does not have to prove that release is deserved.

For certain serious charges, section 515(6) of the Criminal Code reverses that burden, and the accused must show why release is justified. This reverse onus applies to charges such as some firearm and violence offences and to a person charged with an offence while already released on another. In these cases, a strong, detailed release plan matters most, since the starting point is stricter.

04

What a Surety Is and What They Take On

A surety is a person, usually family or a close friend, who agrees to supervise the accused in the community and pledges an amount of money that can be forfeited if the accused breaches the conditions imposed. The court examines a proposed surety's character, finances, any record, and their real ability to supervise, and the surety may be questioned under oath.

Two points matter for sureties. In some circumstances, such as where the accused or surety lives outside the region or is not ordinarily a resident of Ontario, the court can require the pledged amount to be deposited as cash before release, rather than simply promised on paper. It is also against the law to accept payment for acting as a surety.

Bail Conditions, Breach
& If Bail Is Denied

Common Bail Conditions

  • No contact with the complainant or witnesses
  • Living at a set address, sometimes with the surety
  • A curfew or house arrest
  • Reporting regularly to police or a bail supervisor
  • No weapons
  • Surrendering a passport or staying within a set area

Conditions must be no more restrictive than necessary and connected to a real risk in the case.

What Happens If Bail Is Breached

  • Breaching any bail condition is a separate criminal offence, on top of the original charge
  • It can lead to arrest, and getting released a second time is much harder, since a breach usually puts the onus on the accused to show why release should be granted again
  • The Crown can also ask the court to cancel the original release
  • A condition that cannot realistically be followed is worth challenging before it is imposed, not after it becomes a problem

If Bail Is Denied

  • A bail review in the Superior Court under section 520 of the Criminal Code, where a judge reconsiders the decision. It generally requires a material change, such as a new surety or an improved plan, or an error at the first hearing
  • An automatic detention review under section 525 of the Criminal Code. If an accused is held for 90 days without trial, the institution holding the person must bring the matter back before the court so a judge can consider again whether continued detention is still justified

Why Early Legal Help Matters

  • A bail hearing is often won or lost on preparation
  • The plan presented to the court — where the accused will live, who will provide supervision, and how conditions will be met — is what the court weighs against the Crown's concerns
  • Early legal help allows a realistic plan to be assembled, a suitable surety to be lined up, and the risks to be addressed head-on before the hearing rather than after
  • For an Indigenous accused, a newcomer to Canada, or someone arrested far from a courthouse, section 493.2 of the Criminal Code requires the court to give particular attention to these circumstances, and a lawyer can put the relevant considerations before the court
  • Because bail decisions come quickly, the sooner a lawyer is retained, the more can be done

Held for a Bail Hearing?

When an arrest leads to custody, the first hours before a bail hearing matter most. That is when a release plan comes together, and early legal advice can decide whether the accused goes home. Call Foote Law in Orangeville at 519-940-8309.

519-940-8309
Request a Consultation →
The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.